Friday, March 9, 2018

On the Needles 6

Knitting

I'm almost halfway done with the second lace section on my shawl. There are 34 rows of 200 stitches and 18 rows of 400 stitches left.

The lace has gotten...interesting. Unlike in almost everything I've knitted lately, every row has a completely different set of instructions, which means it takes a lot more focus than the other knitting I've been doing. I'm not even sure I like how the lace works. But I'm not frustrated enough with it to stop, because I still feel like I'm making progress. And if I don't like the lace when it's done, at least it's a nice color and I can admire its complexity.

Drawing

Today is Pokemon day 467, Magmortar. I've probably said this before, but Gen 4 has a run of uncommonly ugly Pokemon, and I can't wait till the design improves again so I can tell whether my technique is improving.

Pokemon Art Challenge #467: Magmortar, the Blast Pokemon

Wednesday, March 7, 2018

On Vacation 1: A Small-Town Simacrulum

I went to Florida last week. Mostly to visit my sister, who lives there, but also so she could show me around Disney World. Having not been to Disney World in about twelve years, I was a little nervous about whether I would actually enjoy being there as an adult.

The first day, the idea that I was no longer the sort of person who would enjoy Disney World seemed entirely plausible. I took a long walk from my hotel to Disney Springs, which is basically Disney World's shopping district, and then spent another couple of hours looking for a place to sit and get some work done. Which led to me examining the structure of the park in ways the designers probably don't want guests doing, at least not while they're there.

The first thing I noticed was the sound design, something my sister's vlog has primed me to pay attention to. The soundscapes in different areas of a park work best when you're just passing through; if you sit down in the wrong place, as I did under a sandwich shop awning, and then again at an ice cream place, the different styles of music conflict in ways that make it hard to focus.

The second thing that occurred to me, while I was making my way from the ice cream shop to the Starbucks at the other end of the park, was that I really felt like a tourist, but that there was nothing wrong with feeling like a tourist. In fact, Disney World is, if nothing else, the archetypal experience of being a tourist, because everyone is a tourist, and there are no natives to offend.

That in itself was a weird feeling, and it made the rest of Disney Springs feel especially fake. Like it wasn't trying to be anything realer than a deliberate imitation of a place. Except for the Starbucks. It felt like a real Starbucks, and it had power strips at all the tables, so I spent the afternoon working there.

By the time my sister came to pick me up for dinner, I'd realized that I would need to actively get myself into a theme-park-appreciating mindset the next day, otherwise I'd spend the whole time feeling like a tourist, nitpicking and not actually enjoy my time in the parks. I prepared myself the next morning by listening to the Moana soundtrack with my sister as she drove us to Epcot, and by the time we got there, I was ready to take Disney's constructed World as it presented itself. To be, not a nitpicky tourist in a cardboard village, but a gracious guest in the archetypal experience of being a guest.

Update: The sequel to this post is on my sister's Youtube channel in Glorious Jump-Cut-o-Vision.

Monday, March 5, 2018

On the Stack 3: My Complicated Relationship With Blue/Green Decks

I’m going to try to make this as comprehensible to non-Magic players as I can. If I miss something, please ask.

Magic: the Gathering has five colors of mana: white-blue-black-red-green (and sometimes colorless acts like a color). Each lets you cast different kinds of spells, and is associated with different deck archetypes and in-game philosophies. My favorite color to play is green, the color of large creatures that trample over other creatures, and spells that make extra mana and/or make creatures stronger and fight each other. My least favorite, at least until very recently, is blue, the color of small flying and swimming creatures, drawing lots of cards, and preventing your opponent from doing things. Playing green, you don’t really care what your opponent is doing. Playing blue, you care a lot. And as a relatively inexperienced Magic player, what my opponent is doing is just one more complicated thing to keep track of as I’m figuring out how my deck works.

The weird thing is that, as I get better at the game, blue has begun to make sense. Counterspells used to be agonizing decisions—do I keep you from weakening my creature now, or save the card for just in case you cast your most powerful creature? Now, I find myself with no qualms about saying “no you don’t” when I think I can benefit most from it.

How did I learn this, when I’m too intimidated by blue to build decks with it? The answer has two parts: Limited events and Ixalan block.

In a Limited event, you build a deck on the spot from cards that are given to you—either as whole booster packs, or drafted from packs passed around the table. Since you don’t get to choose what cards you come into the event with, you have to work with whatever strategy is best represented in your card pool.

The most recent “block” of Magic sets is Ixalan and Rivals of Ixalan, which tell the story of a search for a lost golden city on a Mesoamerica-inspired world. Four different groups, each associated with a different combination of colors, are competing to get there first; and, most importantly for this essay, the indigenous merfolk are represented by some unusually powerful cards, and they’re in blue and green, my most and least favorite colors.

For most of the last six months, which is how long one or both of these sets has been drafted regularly at Lady Planeswalkers, I’d played the other factions. I had good results with pirates; dinosaurs have been less consistent, but I’ve collected enough of them to make a Commander deck; and vampires was less fun, which makes me think I’m less fond of black (the color of killing things and bringing them back to life) than I used to be. Then, about a month ago, I opened a Merfolk Mistbinder at the start of the draft and went “What the hell, let’s try Merfolk.”

And it worked. I won two rounds that night, with a deck of small creatures and ways to make them bigger (and a few counterspells), and I wasn’t quite sure how. But playing that deck felt good, like I’d set myself a puzzle and was solving it correctly more often than not. Every time a play worked out, I felt something click into place in my brain; and at the end of the night, I was proud of myself. Last Tuesday went much the same way: I drafted Merfolk for no particular reason, with bigger creatures and more control-y cards this time, and the puzzle thing happened again. It turns out this deck scratches an itch other archetypes don’t.

But I don’t know how to replicate it yet. Is it just the feeling of the Merfolk tribal synergy, that they reinforce each other in ways the other factions don’t? Might my pirate combo deck, if I’m ever around on the right day to play it, feel as good to play? And even with all the Merfolk cards I’ve accumulated by drafting them twice, I don’t know how to put them together into an effective Standard deck. I still don’t feel like I know how to play blue well enough.

Friday, March 2, 2018

On the Needles 5

Knitting

I've made a little more progress on the Springtide Shawl test knit, but didn't have a chance to take a photo yesterday. I'm up into the block of 200-stitch rows, but I still somehow think I'll get it done in time. In fact, I'm so confident that I started making a sleep mask as a side project, because as the sun starts coming up earlier, I'm finding I actually need a sleep mask. (The confidence was mostly sarcastic; the need for a sleep mask was not.

Drawing

Today is Pokemon day 460.

Writing

On Monday, I posted an essay I'm particularly proud of, on how to teach Homestuck in an undergrad literature class. I recommend you read it, if you haven't already, and maybe check out the Homestuck literary analysis blog I used to write with my sister (linked from that post).

Deckbuilding

I've put together a Locust God list for Modern, but I'm waiting to buy the cards until we see how much the release of Masters 25 drives down prices (and until Lady Planeswalkers has a Modern night, probably). And this week at Lady Planeswalkers, I drafted Merfolk, including a Tishana and a Nezahal (who is not a merfolk but plays well with them), and won two rounds again. And then I opened a Hadana's Climb in one of my prize packs (right after I sold the one I got in last month's draft), and I'm taking all of that together as a sign that I should make a Merfolk standard deck. More on that, and my personal journey toward understanding green/blue decks, on Monday.

Wednesday, February 28, 2018

On Being Bad at Things

I don’t like practicing things. I never have. I gave up piano lessons in eighth grade, after nine years, because my teacher wanted me to spend more than half an hour a day playing scales, and I finally worked up the courage to say no.

Actually, that first thing isn’t really correct. I don’t like practicing that doesn’t seem to have a point. I want to get good at things, without looking like I'm not good at them, and in my teenage brain, there was no connection between stumbling over endless scales and etudes and the parts of music I really wanted to be good at. So I started playing guitar instead, and happily spent hours on weekends playing songs I actually wanted to know how to play, with no one judging me based on how much time I spent playing.

There’s no getting around the fact that becoming good at something requires that you be bad at it first. But the way we teach that to kids is often counterproductive. “Practice makes perfect” is basically meaningless, and also not true. You’re never going to be perfect at anything; that would require an infinite amount of practice. The best you can ever be is amazing. Not that we tell children to strive to be amazing. Nor do we tell them it’s okay to look like you’re bad at something when you’re bad at that thing.

My dad came closer to making sense with a Russian proverb: “Repetition is the mother of learning.” But I got tired of him saying that long before I found any skill I wanted to learn by repeating it. And when I did find one, I was surprised to learn that I’d been practicing for months before I even noticed I was bad at it.

That was knitting. I spent six weeks repeating a single gesture, and didn’t realize that’s what was going on because I was focused on the scarf at the end of the journey. And even then, I didn’t put two and two together until nearly five years later, when I started watching art streams on Twitch, including marathons of Bob Ross’ The Joy of Painting (and knitting while I watched, of course).

Image result for bob ross photos

Bob Ross put it this way: “Talent is a pursued interest. Anything you practice, you can do.” That got me thinking. As a kid, everyone told me I was talented, rather than skilled, and that made me think I should be able to do everything right the first time, and that it reflected badly on me if I didn't. (This is another thing I only noticed years later, with the strength of Tumblr Discourse behind it.) What if talent and skill were the same thing? That might actually make practicing worth it.

At about the same time, Alex Steacy announced that he was going to start a webcomic (warning: full of toilet humor), so he could learn to be okay with being bad at drawing. I read the comic, and watched a few of his drawing streams, and between Bob and Alex I realized I wanted to become good at drawing, and that the way to become good at drawing was to spend some time being bad at drawing first. It was okay to look bad, to be discordant, as long as you were doing something you enjoyed and were dedicated to getting better at it. And so I started the Pokemon Art Challenge, which I post about in my weekly crafting updates. (That link is to the series in chronological order, so you can see how much I’ve improved since November 2016.) And the really funny thing about that is, even my bad drawings get praise from people who don't draw at all, because they can see the work I'm putting into it, even when the result isn't great.

In spite of all this positive reinforcement, my brain doesn't entirely get how being bad at things leads to being good at things. I have to teach it one hobby at a time. My most recent success has been with Magic: the Gathering. Last fall I posted about stepping back from Magic until I no longer put so much of my self-worth into it, and losing was no longer the end of the world. Some time after that, I started going to Lady Planeswalkers events again, and I told myself I was going less to play the game and more to spend time with interesting, nice people. And the more I went, the more I convinced myself it wasn’t about doing well at the game, the better I began to do at the game. Last night was my second draft this month where I won two rounds in a row.

Not sure what hobby is next. Maybe I’ll go back to music, and try to teach myself not to be self-conscious about practicing singing.

Here’s to a grand future of being bad at stuff.

Monday, February 26, 2018

On Homestuck: A Syllabus

Homestuck is a big deal. Written by Andrew Hussie on mspaintadventures.com between April 2009 and October 2016, it was basically the bible of the internet for American high school and college students, a multimedia introduction to webcomics and long-form science fantasy and a crash course on thirty years of popular culture that challenged gender roles, redefined the relationship between author and fandom, and ended by deconstructing its own narrative structure.

Image result for homestuck house symbol
I keep coming up with clever tag lines for this blog post,
but none of them really fit. So here's some music to listen
to while you read.

It's easy enough to argue that it didn't do anything particularly new or revolutionary--fans becoming creators of ongoing series is not unusual (that's how Doctor Who keeps going, after all), and even the interactive segments, as the Geek loves to remind me, were preempted by Portal, an interactive novel from the 80s. But every generation needs its own reason to care about the world and the past, and for the people we call Young Millennials and Old Generation Z, Homestuck has often been a key conversation starter about important topics. Like "hey, Dave's brother is kind of a terrible father," or "is Vriska a good person or a bad person," or "having a moirail sounds nice; how do I find one?"

And for all the impact Homestuck has had on people my age and a little younger, there's been remarkably little scholarly writing about it and how it and its readers interact with the culture that produced it. There's a few discourse analyses on Google Scholar, not to mention the I Like Homestuck Project, the Tumblr blog my sister and I wrote from 2014 to 2016 (which is still somehow gaining followers, and if that doesn't speak to the cultural importance of Homestuck I don't know what does), but nothing that really situates it in the world it was written for. So at some point around the end of the comic, I started developing a syllabus for a hypothetical upper-level undergraduate course on the narrative construction and social themes of Homestuck. Here's a draft of that, with assignment descriptions inserted as they come up. Feedback is welcome.


Friday, February 23, 2018

On the Needles 4

Here's what I've been working on this week.

Knitting

Right after I posted my last crafting update, I decided to use a completely different yarn for the shawl I'm test knitting. At time of posting, I'm halfway through the first of three lace sections.


It's a half-pi shawl, which means the finished shape will be as close to a half circle as is mathematically possible with whole numbers of stitches. The practical result is that each lace section has twice as many stitches per row as the last one. So I'm hoping I finish the first lace section quickly, because the last lace section will have almost 400 stitches in each row.

Drawing

Here are this week's Pokemon. Today is day 453: Croagunk.
Pokemon Art Challenge #453: Croagunk, the Toxic Mouth Pokemon